TL;DR
The average interstate move costs $4,890, but prices vary widely depending on distance, home size, and timing. This guide ranks the best-rated long-distance movers based on FMCSA licensing, pricing transparency, claims rates, and what real customers say on forums. AmeriSafe Van Lines tops our list for its coordinator-led model with dual carrier/broker authority. U-Pack is the budget standout for DIY movers. Booking between October and April can save you 30-40% regardless of which company you choose.
Why This List Exists (And Why You Should Be Skeptical of Most)
FMCSA complaints about moving companies doubled from 4,340 to 8,295 between 2020 and 2021. Hostage-load incidents, where movers refuse to unload your belongings until you pay more than the original quote, rose 189% since 2022. The moving industry generated $23.1 billion in revenue in 2024, and not all of it was earned honestly.
Most “best of” lists rank movers by editorial opinion or, worse, by who pays the most for placement. This guide ranks them by what actually matters to the person writing the check: pricing transparency, FMCSA compliance, whether a company is a broker or a carrier (or both), claims rates, and what real customers report on Reddit, Bogleheads, and other forums.
Before we get into individual profiles, here’s the full comparison at a glance.
Get a free long-distance quote from AmeriSafe Van Lines to compare against the options below.
At-a-Glance Comparison: Best Rated Long Distance Movers
Company | Best For | Pricing Model | Deposit Required | Carrier/Broker | Key Standout | Notable Limitation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
AmeriSafe Van Lines | Coordinator-led moves, single point of contact | Custom quote | Yes (non-refundable after 72 hrs) | Both (dual authority) | Dedicated coordinator + carrier flexibility | Smaller fleet than mega van lines |
Allied Van Lines | No-deposit booking | Weight-based | None | Carrier | No deposit + extra coverage for sets | Credit card payment fee |
American Van Lines | Flat-rate pricing, specialty items | Flat rate | Yes | Carrier | Sub-2% claims rate | No GPS tracking |
Safeway Moving | Affordable full-service + free storage | Weight-based | 10-18% | Carrier | 30 days free storage | Higher-than-average deposit |
Atlas Van Lines | Zero deposit + move tracking | Weight-based | None | Carrier | Online move portal, low complaint rate | Premium pricing |
North American Van Lines | À la carte customization | À la carte | Yes (amount unclear) | Carrier | Pick only the services you need | Clunky website, confusing deposits |
Colonial Van Lines | Binding estimates, price certainty | Binding quote | 20-30% | Broker | Price match guarantee | Very high upfront deposit |
United Van Lines | Large-scale full-service moves | Weight-based | Yes | Carrier | 93% on-time rate, MyUnited Portal | Not BBB accredited |
U-Pack | Budget DIY movers | Space-based | Varies | Carrier (freight) | Pay only for space used | You load and unload yourself |
Now for the detailed breakdown of each mover.
1. AmeriSafe Van Lines
Best for: Coordinator-led nationwide moves with a single point of contact
AmeriSafe operates as both a Licensed Interstate Motor Carrier and a Licensed Interstate Moving Broker, holding dual authority from the FMCSA (authorized for household goods). This means the company can assign its own trucks on select routes or tap partner carriers for national coverage, depending on the lane and capacity. Headquartered in Boynton Beach, Florida, AmeriSafe also holds Florida intrastate and broker licensing.
Key features:
Dedicated move coordinator from quote through delivery, with separate sales and customer service phone lines for clear routing
Full and partial packing, short and long-term storage, senior moves, special handling for items like pianos and antiques, and commercial relocations
Publishes FMCSA consumer-rights documents (Rights and Responsibilities, Ready to Move brochure) and arbitration information directly on its website
Clear deposit and refund policy: deposits become non-refundable after 72 hours from signing
Published customer reviews with named move scenarios (Oregon to Texas, Chicago to Monterey, and others)
Honest tradeoffs:
Smaller fleet (6 power units) compared to mega van lines like United or Atlas. This means some moves will be handled by partner carriers rather than AmeriSafe’s own trucks.
No standardized package tiers are published online. You’ll need to call or submit a quote form for pricing.
The 72-hour non-refundable deposit window requires you to be fairly certain before committing.
The dual-authority model is actually a meaningful differentiator. As we’ll explain in the carrier vs. broker section below, many consumers are told to “avoid brokers at all costs,” but that advice is oversimplified. AmeriSafe’s structure allows it to function as a carrier where possible and coordinate through partners where necessary, all through a single point of contact.
You can read verified customer reviews on the AmeriSafe website.
2. Allied Van Lines
Best for: Flexibility and no-deposit bookings
Allied Van Lines is one of the most experienced names in the industry and does not require a deposit to book your move. That alone sets it apart, since large upfront deposits are a top consumer protection concern in long-distance moving.
Key features:
No deposit required to book
Extra coverage for pairs and sets of items (useful for matching furniture, china sets, or sentimental collections)
Considers any move over 400 miles to be long-distance
Extensive agent network across the country
Pricing data:
For a 2,800-mile move, Allied’s estimates ranged from $12,554 to $13,886 for standard service (no packing or add-ons included). That puts it on the higher end for cross-country relocations.
Honest tradeoffs:
Charges a fee for credit card payments. For large moving bills, that fee adds up fast.
Does not offer day-certain delivery unless you have a small shipment. If you need your belongings on a specific date, this is a problem.
BBB complaints point to challenges with damage claims, particularly around reimbursement timelines. Multiple customers report deliveries arriving weeks late.
What users say:
Practitioners on Reddit and consumer forums frequently flag Allied’s delivery windows as frustratingly vague. The no-deposit policy earns goodwill, but delayed shipments erode it.
3. American Van Lines
Best for: Flat-rate pricing and high-value or specialty items
American Van Lines charges a flat rate and includes access to all of its moving services, including piano moving and antique handling. The company also conducts background checks on its workers, including drug tests and screenings.
Key features:
Flat-rate pricing model (no weight-based surprises)
Claims rate under 2%, compared to the industry average of 4-5%
On-time delivery rate around 90%, above the industry average for long-distance moves
Background-checked crews
Honest tradeoffs:
No GPS tracking for shipments. Many customers now expect real-time visibility, and American Van Lines doesn’t offer it.
Flat-rate pricing can be higher than weight-based quotes for smaller, lighter moves.
Less flexible than à la carte options if you only need partial services.
The sub-2% claims rate is the standout number here. If you’re moving a houseful of antiques or a grand piano, that statistic matters more than almost anything else on this list.
4. Safeway Moving
Best for: Affordable full-service moves with free storage
Safeway is a veteran-owned interstate moving company that offers 30 days of free storage on interstate moves. For anyone dealing with a gap between move-out and move-in dates, that’s a genuine cost saver. Understanding storage options during a move can help you determine whether this perk applies to your situation.
Key features:
30 days of free storage included on interstate moves
Veteran-owned company
Positioned as a value option below the premium pricing of major van lines
Full-service capabilities, including packing
Honest tradeoffs:
Requires a 10-18% deposit for long-distance moves, which is higher than several competitors on this list.
Charges a 1-3% fee for credit card payments, though the company says this fee is waived for deposits.
Fewer published independent reviews compared to legacy van lines.
What users say:
Safeway gets mixed reactions online. The free storage offer draws people in, but the deposit requirement makes some forum users hesitant, especially given how strongly Reddit communities warn against large upfront payments.
5. Atlas Van Lines
Best for: Zero deposits and online move tracking
Atlas Van Lines charges no upfront deposits and no fee for paying by credit card (though you get a 1% discount for paying via e-check). Its online move portal lets you track your shipment, access moving documents, receive notifications, and make payments.
Key features:
Zero deposit required
No credit card payment fees
Online move portal with shipment tracking and document access
One of the lowest rates of BBB and DOT complaints when adjusted by fleet size
Approximately 2,800 trucks in its network (the second-largest van line)
Honest tradeoffs:
Premium pricing. Atlas is not the budget option.
As a large van line, your actual move may be handled by a local agent, which means variable crew quality.
The portal is helpful, but doesn’t replace direct communication when issues arise.
Atlas is NerdWallet’s top pick, and the combination of zero deposits, no card fees, and low complaint rates makes it a strong choice for risk-averse movers willing to pay a premium.
6. North American Van Lines
Best for: À la carte service customization
North American Van Lines has over 90 years of experience and operates through 500+ locations nationwide. The key differentiator is its à la carte pricing model: you pick and choose only the services you need.
Key features:
À la carte pricing (pay only for services you select)
90+ years of industry experience
500+ locations for broad coverage
Exceptionally high customer review scores across multiple platforms
Honest tradeoffs:
The website is clunky and difficult to navigate.
Deposit amounts and payment terms are hard to nail down before you’re deep into the quoting process.
À la carte pricing can backfire if you underestimate what you need and have to add services later at higher rates.
The à la carte model is genuinely useful if you’re a good planner. Some companies charge you for everything, whether you need it or not. North American lets you strip out what you don’t want. Just make sure you understand what you’re opting out of before moving day.
7. Colonial Van Lines
Best for: Binding estimates and price match guarantee
Colonial offers binding estimates, which means the price they quote is the price you pay. You can adjust estimates with their Quality Assurance team up until your moving date. They also offer a price match guarantee.
Key features:
Binding estimates (guaranteed pricing)
Price match guarantee
Quotes based on load weight, locations, and moving dates
Adjustable estimates through a dedicated QA team
Honest tradeoffs:
Requires a very high upfront deposit, typically 20-30% of the total cost. For a 960-mile full-service move, one reported deposit was $3,261.
High deposits are the number-one red flag that consumer protection advocates and the FMCSA target in enforcement actions.
Binding estimates protect you from price increases but can also mean you pay more if your shipment ends up lighter than estimated.
The deposit issue is serious. Practitioners on Reddit and consumer forums consistently warn against companies requiring large upfront payments. For a detailed look at deposit red flags, it helps to understand what’s normal and what should make you walk away. Colonial’s binding estimate is valuable, but the deposit size is a real concern.
8. United Van Lines
Best for: Large-scale full-service moves
United Van Lines moves more households across the country than almost any other carrier. They deliver approximately 93% of moves on time, and customers rate them around 4.2 out of 5.
Key features:
93% on-time delivery rate
MyUnited Portal for document access, tracking, and communication
Massive network and fleet for handling large, complex moves
Long track record as one of the most recognized names in moving
Honest tradeoffs:
Not BBB accredited. For a company this large, that’s a notable gap.
Reports of damaged or missing items, with some customer dissatisfaction about the claims process.
As with all mega van lines, local agents handle the actual work, resulting in inconsistent experiences.
United’s scale is both its strength and its weakness. The infrastructure to handle a 5-bedroom cross-country move is there. But the individual experience depends heavily on which local agent crew shows up at your door.
9. U-Pack
Best for: Budget-conscious DIY movers
U-Pack is a hybrid option: you load and unload your belongings, and they handle the transport. It’s a freight-based service, not a traditional mover, which makes it significantly cheaper.
Key features:
You load, they drive (you save on labor costs)
Pricing based on actual space used, not estimates that inflate on moving day.
Moving containers generally cost $3,000-$5,000 for long-distance, well below full-service rates
Reliable transit times through the ABF Freight network
Honest tradeoffs:
You do all the loading and unloading yourself. This is physically demanding and time-consuming.
No packing services, no furniture disassembly, no specialty item handling.
Not suitable for seniors, families with young children, or anyone with mobility limitations.
What Reddit says:
On r/moving, U-Pack gets recommended more than almost any other option. Users appreciate that the pricing model charges based on actual space used, giving them control over the final cost. One common refrain: “U-Pack is the way to go if you don’t mind the labor.”
Members of the Bogleheads forum (a high-trust financial community) echo this sentiment. They note that for every success story with a full-service mover, there are horror stories, and several members recommend U-Pack or similar freight-based options to avoid those risks entirely.
How to Choose the Right Long-Distance Mover
The list above gives you options. This section gives you the knowledge to evaluate any mover, including ones not on this list.
Carrier vs. Broker: What It Actually Means
A carrier owns trucks and employs the crews who physically move your stuff. A broker takes your booking and hires another company to do the work. The FMCSA’s Operation Protect Your Move has targeted broker-facilitated fraud specifically because the accountability chain breaks down when multiple companies are involved.
But here’s the nuance most articles miss: the idea of “avoiding brokers” is often misleading. Most long-distance moving companies operate as both carriers and brokers, depending on the route. A company might run its own trucks between Florida and New York, but broker a move from Montana to Maine because it doesn’t have trucks on that lane.
AmeriSafe Van Lines holds dual carrier/broker authority from the FMCSA, which means it can assign its own trucks where available and coordinate through vetted partners on other routes. The key is transparency about who’s actually performing your move. Any mover, broker, or carrier should tell you exactly which company will show up before moving day.
For a deeper explanation of industry terminology, the vetting guide for long-distance movers breaks down the jargon.
Binding vs. Non-Binding vs. Not-to-Exceed Estimates
This is where people get burned most often, and it rarely gets explained properly.
Binding estimate: The price is locked. You pay that amount regardless of whether your shipment weighs more or less than projected. Good for certainty. Bad if your shipment ends up lighter (you still pay the quoted price).
Non-binding estimate: The final price is based on actual weight. If your shipment is heavier than estimated, you pay more. The FMCSA’s 110% Rule provides a safety net here: at delivery, you cannot be required to pay more than 110% of the original estimate. The mover has 30 days to bill you for the remaining balance.
Not-to-exceed estimate: The best of both worlds. The price is capped at the quoted amount, but if your shipment weighs less, you pay less. Not every company offers this.
Getting an in-home estimate (virtual or in-person) is the single most effective way to ensure your estimate is accurate. Phone and online quotes based on your self-reported inventory are almost always less reliable.
Shared Truck vs. Dedicated Truck
This is the number one reason delivery windows for long-distance moves are vague, yet almost no ranking list explains it.
Most long-distance movers use shared trucks. Your belongings share space with shipments from other customers heading in the same general direction. The truck makes multiple stops, which can add days or even a week to your delivery window.
A dedicated truck is exclusively yours. Your stuff goes on, the truck drives to your destination, and your stuff comes off. But dedicated trucks average around $10,000 for a 1,000-1,300-mile haul, making them roughly double the cost of shared transport.
If your delivery window matters (and it usually does), ask every mover whether your shipment will be on a shared or dedicated truck. Then weigh the cost difference against the inconvenience of waiting.
Valuation Coverage: The 60-Cent Trap
By federal law, movers must offer two levels of coverage:
Released value (free, included): Pays 60 cents per pound per article. A 50-pound TV worth $800 would pay out just $30. This is essentially worthless for anything valuable.
Full Value Protection (costs extra): The mover is liable for the full replacement value or repair cost of damaged or lost items. The premium varies, but it’s typically 1-2% of your declared shipment value.
The FMCSA has documented persistent violations in this area, with movers defaulting to released value without proper disclosure. Always confirm in writing which coverage applies to your move. If a mover doesn’t explain both options clearly, that’s a red flag.
For more on identifying and avoiding moving scams, it’s worth reading up before signing anything.
Red Flags to Watch For
Based on FMCSA enforcement data and consistent patterns from Reddit, Bogleheads, and consumer forums:
Lowball quotes significantly below competitors. If one estimate is 40% cheaper than every other quote, the final bill won’t be.
Large upfront deposits (above 20%). This is the most common precursor to hostage-load situations.
No physical address or USDOT number. Every legitimate mover has both. Verify through the FMCSA SAFER database.
Refusing to do an in-home or virtual survey. Accurate estimates require seeing your stuff.
Demanding cash only. Legitimate companies accept credit cards and checks.
No written estimate. If it’s not on paper, it doesn’t exist.
Bogleheads forum members offer a tactical tip worth repeating: call highly rated local movers and ask them to recommend smaller companies that do interstate moves. These referrals often yield better service at lower cost, though you need to book further in advance.
What Does a Long-Distance Move Actually Cost?
Pricing varies enormously based on distance, home size, weight, and season. Here’s what the data shows:
Scenario | Cost Range | Source Context |
|---|---|---|
Average interstate move (all sizes) | $4,890 | Industry-wide average |
2-3 bedroom, 500-1,000 miles | $3,060-$5,280 | moveBuddha 2026 data |
960-mile interstate (standard service) | $6,277-$8,964 | U.S. News sourced estimates |
960-mile interstate (full service) | $9,061-$11,164 | U.S. News sourced estimates |
Cross-country (2,500+ miles) | $10,000-$17,000 | Moving Hub pricing data |
Major van lines average | ~$8,800 | Industry aggregation |
Smaller companies average | ~$5,000 | Industry aggregation |
U-Pack / container (long-distance) | $3,000-$5,000 | Community-reported pricing |
Hidden Costs That Inflate Your Bill
The base quote is never the full picture. Budget for these:
Fuel surcharges: Typically 10-20% of base cost. As of May 2026, moving prices have risen by approximately 21% due to higher fuel costs, with the steepest increases in California, Oregon, and Washington.
Stair fees: Usually $50-$100 per flight.
Long carry charges: If the truck can’t park within a certain distance of your door, expect an extra $100-$200.
Storage-in-transit: If your new home isn’t ready, short-term storage costs $100- $300/month or more, depending on volume.
Packing materials: Full packing service can add $500-$2,000, depending on home size.
Seasonal Timing Saves Real Money
Summer is the most expensive season to move. Roughly 45% of all moves happen between May and August, which spikes demand and tightens availability. Rates jump 30-40% compared to off-peak months.
The cheapest months to hire movers are November through January. If you have any flexibility on timing, shifting your move even a few weeks into the off-peak window can save thousands. Mid-month and mid-week moves are also typically cheaper than end-of-month or weekend bookings.
Planning your interstate move? Get a personalized quote to see how timing affects your price.
How We Ranked These Movers
Every company on this list was evaluated across five dimensions:
FMCSA licensing verification. We confirmed each company’s operating authority, entity type (carrier, broker, or both), and complaint history through the FMCSA SAFER database.
Pricing transparency. Companies that publish clear pricing models, explain their estimate types, and disclose fees scored higher than those requiring you to call just to learn the basics.
Customer sentiment across multiple platforms. We cross-referenced BBB ratings, Google reviews, Trustpilot scores, and real discussions on Reddit and financial forums like Bogleheads.
Claims rate and on-time delivery. Where published data was available, we factored in how often things go wrong and how often deliveries arrive on time.
Consumer protection practices. Does the company publish FMCSA-required documents? Explain valuation coverage? Offer clear cancellation policies? These details separate legitimate operations from fly-by-night outfits.
The best-rated long-distance movers aren’t always the biggest or the cheapest. They’re the ones that combine fair pricing with honest communication and verifiable credentials.
Choosing Your Mover: Final Advice
Get at least three quotes. Compare not just the price, but the estimate type (binding vs. non-binding), the deposit amount, the delivery window, and whether your shipment will share a truck. Verify every company in the FMCSA SAFER database before signing anything.
If you want a coordinator-led experience where one person manages your move from start to finish, with the flexibility of both carrier and broker authority, contact AmeriSafe Van Lines to get a personalized quote for your route.
Frequently Asked Questions
What qualifies as a long-distance move?
Most carriers define a long-distance move as anything over 400 miles or crossing state lines. Some companies use 100 miles as the threshold. Interstate moves are regulated by the FMCSA regardless of distance.
How far in advance should I book a long-distance mover?
For summer moves (May through August), book 6-8 weeks in advance. Off-peak moves can often be booked 3-4 weeks out. The earlier you book, the more leverage you have on pricing and scheduling.
What is the FMCSA’s 110% Rule?
If you have a non-binding estimate, federal regulations state that the mover cannot require you to pay more than 110% of the estimated cost at delivery. The mover has 30 days after delivery to bill you for any remaining charges above that threshold.
Should I hire a carrier or a broker?
The answer is more nuanced than most guides suggest. Many legitimate companies operate as both, using their own trucks on certain routes and partnering with other carriers on others. The key question isn’t “are you a broker,” but “who will physically perform my move, and what happens if something goes wrong?” Companies with dual authority, like AmeriSafe Van Lines, can offer flexibility while maintaining a single point of accountability.
What’s the difference between released value and full value protection?
Released value coverage is free but pays only 60 cents per pound per item. A 50-pound TV worth $800 would pay out $30. Full Value Protection costs extra (usually 1-2% of your declared shipment value) but covers the full replacement cost or repair of damaged items. Always opt for Full Value Protection if your belongings have real monetary or sentimental value.
Can I negotiate moving costs?
Yes. Moving quotes are not fixed retail prices. You can negotiate, especially during off-peak months when companies have excess capacity. Getting multiple quotes gives you the strongest negotiating position. Mention competing offers. Many companies will adjust pricing rather than lose a booking.
What items can’t movers transport?
Federal regulations prohibit movers from transporting hazardous materials, including propane tanks, gasoline, fireworks, ammunition, and certain cleaning chemicals. Most movers also won’t transport perishable food, plants, or pets. Some refuse to carry irreplaceable items like family photo albums or important documents, advising you to transport them yourself.
How do I file a complaint against a moving company?
You can file complaints through the FMCSA’s National Consumer Complaint Database at 1-888-DOT-SAFT (1-888-368-7238) or online through the FMCSA website. For state-level issues, contact your state’s attorney general’s office. Document everything: take photos of your belongings before the move, keep all contracts and receipts, and note the names of crew members.